The Wind Up Bird Chronicle

All language is but a poor translation.

1.  

   Science is a diverse set of activities in one place at one time, after all; geologists generally don’t do experiments, paleontologists commonly aren’t quantitative, astronomers certainly don’t do fieldwork, biologists can rarely predict the future states of the systems they study, and mathematicians often don’t even work with data. Is it conceivable that there actually could be a single method to describe “science” and yet still exclude astrology, astral projection, and Ouija boards -or is that very goal simply an illusion?
   
   The situation gets even more complicated once we throw some time depth into it. The word scientist came into use only in the mid-1800s, so how could it meaningfully be applied to someone like that alchemist Isaac Newton? If indeed what science is, and what scientists are, can inconsistent across scientific fields and different for each generation, how can we specify a scientific method at all?

   –

   Why I am Not a Scientist: Anthropology and Modern Knowledge (p 62) by Jonathan Marks

   This portion really angered the class. Of course, Jonathan Marks is a scientist and he does not consider astrology, astral projection or the study of Ouija boards a science, this is part of the fun.

   (via thenoobyorker)

   Source: thenoobyorker

   • 34
   • Link
   • science
   • scientism
   • queue
2. 1. vexedstressedboredtodeath reblogged this from thenoobyorker
   2. arynblue likes this
   3. fatnatcat likes this
   4. hc1701 likes this
   5. joebirden likes this
   6. augingembre likes this
   7. esperanzaylibertad likes this
   8. ilikemygrungelikeilikemysteak likes this
   9. mostfleetingofall likes this
   10. downlo likes this
   11. skullforts likes this
   12. whitecolonialism likes this
   13. valentine-wiggintemp reblogged this from thenoobyorker
   14. nutopiancitizen reblogged this from thenoobyorker
   15. dancefloorpolitician likes this
   16. stellikerk likes this
   17. interruptions likes this
   18. anawaqifa reblogged this from thenoobyorker
   19. windupbirdchronicle reblogged this from thenoobyorker
   20. erikonymous likes this
   21. friendofhagrid likes this
   22. aprilpwn reblogged this from adefectiveidealist
   23. fearandwar likes this
   24. whollybabel likes this
   25. jakke said: One thing we can all agree on though is that economics is a science.
   26. ayiman likes this
   27. adefectiveidealist reblogged this from thenoobyorker
   28. thenoobyorker posted this
3. blog comments powered by Disqus